We will now work with the real numbers instead of an arbitrary continuum . Accordingly, let us now use the usual notation for the region . This is not the ordered pair , and we must be vigilant that we do not confuse the two concepts.
Definition 9.1. A sequence is a function from the natural numbers to the real numbers.
By setting , we can think of a sequence as a list of real numbers. We use the notation for such a sequence, or if there is no possibility of confusion, we sometimes abbreviate this and write simply . More generally, we also use the term sequence to refer to a function defined on for any fixed . We notate this by writing for such a sequence.
Definition 9.2. We say that a sequence converges to a point if, for every region containing , there exists such that if , then . If converges to , we write this as:
and call the limit of . If does not converge to any point , we say that the sequence diverges.
Exercise 9.3. Show that if a sequence converges to , then any region containing contains all but finitely many terms in the sequence.
Exercise 9.4. Which of the following sequences converge? Which diverge? If one converges, what does it converge to? If one diverges, what can you say about the nature of its divergence?
Suppose the region
The next theorem tells us that the limits of sequences are unique:
Theorem 9.5. Suppose that
Then .
Sometimes divergent sequences have points that behave like limits, but are not necessarily unique:
Definition 9.6. A point is a sublimit point of if, for every region containing , there exist infinitely many with .
Exercise 9.7. Construct a sequence with two distinct sublimit points. Construct a sequence with infinitely many sublimit points.
Theorem 9.8. Suppose that . Then is the only sublimit point of the sequence .
Definition 9.9. Let be a sequence. A subsequence of is a sequence defined by the composition , where is an injective, order-preserving function. (By order-preserving, we mean that has the property that if , then .)
If we let , we can write , so that is the sequence which is equal to the sequence , where .
Theorem 9.10. If converges to , then so do all of its subsequences.
Theorem 9.11. Let be a sequence and suppose that there exists a subsequence that converges to . Then is a sublimit point of .
The next two lemmas will help prove the converse to Theorem 9.11. Let and for each natural number , define to be the region .
Lemma 9.12. The form a descending collection of regions whose intersection is the point :
Lemma 9.13. Let be a region containing . Then there exists a natural number such that for all .
Theorem 9.14. Let be a sequence with a sublimit point . Then there exists a subsequence that converges to .
Here is another nice application of Lemmas 9.12 and 9.13:
Theorem 9.15. Let . Then if and only if there exists a sequence , with each , that converges to .
Definition 9.16. A sequence is bounded above if there exists such that for all . Similarly, is bounded below if there exists such that for all . We say that is bounded if it is both bounded above and bounded below.
Remark 9.17. Note that the sequence is bounded precisely when the set is bounded.
Theorem 9.18. Every convergent sequence is bounded.
The converse is not always true, but we do have the following:
Theorem 9.19. Every bounded sequence has a convergent subsequence.
(Hint: sometimes this is called the Bolzano–Weierstrass theorem.)
The rest of the sheet is a natural continuation of the idea behind Lemmas 9.12 and 9.13. Mathematicians often use the letters and to denote "small" positive numbers. For example, is small when is large. Keeping this in mind, we can rephrase Lemma 9.13 as follows:
Lemma 9.20. Let be a region containing the point . Then there exists a number such that .
Theorem 9.21. A function is continuous if and only if the following condition holds for each point : for all , there exists such that
By Theorem 5.4
There is a slightly nicer way of writing this theorem. First, we define the absolute value of a real number:
Definition 9.22. The absolute value of a real number is the non-negative number defined by:
Exercise 9.23. Prove that:
Our reformulation of Theorem 9.21 is then:
Theorem 9.24. A function is continuous if and only if the following condition holds for each point : for every , there exists such that
Calculus textbooks often give the condition in this theorem as the definition of continuity. Notice that we have shifted focus to the local behavior of at a point . This suggests that we can define continuity "one point at a time":
Definition 9.25. A function is continuous at if, for every , there exists such that