This sheet connects Galois theory to the classical problem of solving polynomial equations by radicals. We introduce solvable groups and radical extensions, and prove that a polynomial is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable.
Commentary. For centuries, mathematicians sought formulas for solving polynomial equations. The quadratic formula has been known since antiquity; cubic and quartic formulas were discovered in the Renaissance. But the quintic resisted all attempts. Galois theory explains why: a polynomial is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable. Since the symmetric group is not solvable (proved in Sheet 13), there exist quintics with Galois group that cannot be solved by radicals. This is the crowning achievement of Galois theory.
Prerequisites. This sheet uses the following results from earlier sheets:
- Groups, subgroups, normal subgroups, quotient groups (Sheets 1-4)
- Solvable groups (introduced in Sheet 13, Definition 13.47 and Theorem 13.49)
- Field extensions, splitting fields, Galois extensions (Sheets 12-13)
- The Fundamental Theorem of Galois Theory (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.33)
- The simplicity of (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.48)
Solvable Groups#
Definition 14.1. A group is solvable if there exists a chain of subgroups:such that each quotient is abelian.
Theorem 14.2. Every abelian group is solvable.
Theorem 14.3. Every subgroup of a solvable group is solvable.
Theorem 14.4. Every homomorphic image of a solvable group is solvable.
Theorem 14.5. If and both and are solvable, then is solvable.
Example 14.6. is solvable:The quotients are and , both abelian.
Example 14.7. is solvable:
Example 14.8. is not solvable (proved in Sheet 13, Theorem 13.49). Its only nontrivial normal subgroup is , which is nonabelian simple.
Exercise 14.9. Show that every -group is solvable.
Exercise 14.10. Prove that is solvable.
Exercise 14.11. Show that is not solvable for .
Radical Extensions#
Definition 14.12. A field extension is a radical extension if there exists a chain of fields:such that for each , where for some positive integer .
Definition 14.13. A polynomial is solvable by radicals over if its splitting field is contained in some radical extension of .
Example 14.14. The splitting field of over is , which is a radical extension. So is solvable by radicals.
Example 14.15. The splitting field of over is , where . This is a radical extension since:with . So is solvable by radicals.
Example 14.16. The general quadratic is solvable by radicals over any field of characteristic .
Exercise 14.17. Show that the splitting field of over is a radical extension.
Exercise 14.18. Show that any extension obtained by adjoining a square root and then a cube root is a radical extension.
Exercise 14.19. Show that is a radical extension.
The Connection Between Solvability and Galois Groups#
Theorem 14.20. Let be a field of characteristic . If is solvable by radicals, then its Galois group is a solvable group.
Proof Idea. If is the splitting field of and is a radical extension containing , then has a chain of cyclic extensions (adjoining roots of unity and th roots). The Galois group of each step is cyclic (hence abelian), so is solvable. Since is a quotient of , it is solvable.∎
Theorem 14.21. Conversely, if is solvable, then is solvable by radicals.
Theorem 14.22 (Galois's Criterion). A polynomial (with ) is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable.
Example 14.23. is solvable, so every cubic over is solvable by radicals. This is consistent with the cubic formula.
Example 14.24. is solvable, so every quartic over is solvable by radicals. This is consistent with the quartic formula.
Example 14.25. is not solvable, so there exist quintics with Galois group that are not solvable by radicals.
Exercise 14.26. Explain why every quadratic, cubic, and quartic over is solvable by radicals.
Exercise 14.27. Let have Galois group . Is solvable by radicals? Why or why not?
Exercise 14.28. Let be an irreducible quintic with exactly two nonreal roots. Show that its Galois group contains a transposition.
Cyclotomic Extensions and Roots of Unity#
Definition 14.29. A cyclotomic extension of is a field where is a primitive th root of unity.
Theorem 14.30. The Galois group is isomorphic to , the group of units modulo .
Theorem 14.31. is abelian.
Corollary 14.32. Cyclotomic extensions are solvable by radicals.
Example 14.33. For prime, , which is cyclic.
Exercise 14.35. Compute .
Exercise 14.36. Show that is always abelian.
Exercise 14.37. What is ?
Constructible Numbers and Solvability#
Definition 14.38. A real number is constructible if it can be obtained from and using finitely many operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and taking square roots.
Theorem 14.39. A real number is constructible iff is a power of .
Corollary 14.40. The regular -gon is constructible with straightedge and compass iff is a power of .
Corollary 14.41. The cube cannot be doubled, the angle cannot be trisected, and the circle cannot be squared using straightedge and compass.
Exercise 14.42. Show that is not constructible.
Exercise 14.43. Show that is not constructible.
Exercise 14.44. Which regular -gons are constructible for ?
Summary#
We have introduced:
- Solvable groups and their properties
- Radical extensions
- Galois's criterion: solvable by radicals iff solvable Galois group
- Cyclotomic extensions and their abelian Galois groups
- Constructible numbers and their characterization
- Classical impossibility results: doubling the cube, trisecting the angle, squaring the circle