This sheet connects Galois theory to the classical problem of solving polynomial equations by radicals. We introduce solvable groups and radical extensions, and prove that a polynomial is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable.

Commentary. For centuries, mathematicians sought formulas for solving polynomial equations. The quadratic formula has been known since antiquity; cubic and quartic formulas were discovered in the Renaissance. But the quintic resisted all attempts. Galois theory explains why: a polynomial is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable. Since the symmetric group S5S_5 is not solvable (proved in Sheet 13), there exist quintics with Galois group S5S_5 that cannot be solved by radicals. This is the crowning achievement of Galois theory.

Prerequisites. This sheet uses the following results from earlier sheets:

  • Groups, subgroups, normal subgroups, quotient groups (Sheets 1-4)
  • Solvable groups (introduced in Sheet 13, Definition 13.47 and Theorem 13.49)
  • Field extensions, splitting fields, Galois extensions (Sheets 12-13)
  • The Fundamental Theorem of Galois Theory (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.33)
  • The simplicity of A5A_5 (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.48)

Solvable Groups#

Definition 14.1. A group GG is solvable if there exists a chain of subgroups:{e}=G0◃G1◃⋯◃Gn=G\{e\} = G_0 \triangleleft G_1 \triangleleft \cdots \triangleleft G_n = Gsuch that each quotient Gi+1/GiG_{i+1}/G_i is abelian.

Theorem 14.2. Every abelian group is solvable.

Theorem 14.3. Every subgroup of a solvable group is solvable.

Theorem 14.4. Every homomorphic image of a solvable group is solvable.

Theorem 14.5. If N◃GN \triangleleft G and both NN and G/NG/N are solvable, then GG is solvable.

Example 14.6. S3S_3 is solvable:{e}◃A3◃S3.\{e\} \triangleleft A_3 \triangleleft S_3.The quotients are A3≅Z3A_3 \cong \mathbb{Z}_3 and S3/A3≅Z2S_3/A_3 \cong \mathbb{Z}_2, both abelian.

Example 14.7. S4S_4 is solvable:{e}◃V4◃A4◃S4.\{e\} \triangleleft V_4 \triangleleft A_4 \triangleleft S_4.

Example 14.8. S5S_5 is not solvable (proved in Sheet 13, Theorem 13.49). Its only nontrivial normal subgroup is A5A_5, which is nonabelian simple.

Exercise 14.9. Show that every pp-group is solvable.

Exercise 14.10. Prove that A4A_4 is solvable.

Exercise 14.11. Show that SnS_n is not solvable for n≥5n \geq 5.


Radical Extensions#

Definition 14.12. A field extension E/FE/F is a radical extension if there exists a chain of fields:F=F0⊆F1⊆⋯⊆Fn=EF = F_0 \subseteq F_1 \subseteq \cdots \subseteq F_n = Esuch that for each ii, Fi+1=Fi(αi)F_{i+1} = F_i(\alpha_i) where αini∈Fi\alpha_i^{n_i} \in F_i for some positive integer nin_i.

Definition 14.13. A polynomial f(x)∈F[x]f(x) \in F[x] is solvable by radicals over FF if its splitting field is contained in some radical extension of FF.

Example 14.14. The splitting field of x2−2x^2 - 2 over Q\mathbb{Q} is Q(2)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}), which is a radical extension. So x2−2x^2 - 2 is solvable by radicals.

Example 14.15. The splitting field of x3−2x^3 - 2 over Q\mathbb{Q} is Q(23,ω)\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[3]{2}, \omega), where ω=e2πi/3\omega = e^{2\pi i/3}. This is a radical extension since:Q⊆Q(23)⊆Q(23,ω),\mathbb{Q} \subseteq \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[3]{2}) \subseteq \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[3]{2}, \omega),with ω3=1∈Q(23)\omega^3 = 1 \in \mathbb{Q}(\sqrt[3]{2}). So x3−2x^3 - 2 is solvable by radicals.

Example 14.16. The general quadratic ax2+bx+cax^2 + bx + c is solvable by radicals over any field of characteristic ≠2\neq 2.

Exercise 14.17. Show that the splitting field of x4−4x2+2x^4 - 4x^2 + 2 over Q\mathbb{Q} is a radical extension.

Exercise 14.18. Show that any extension obtained by adjoining a square root and then a cube root is a radical extension.

Exercise 14.19. Show that Q(2,3)/Q\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3})/\mathbb{Q} is a radical extension.


The Connection Between Solvability and Galois Groups#

Theorem 14.20. Let FF be a field of characteristic 00. If f(x)∈F[x]f(x) \in F[x] is solvable by radicals, then its Galois group GfG_f is a solvable group.

Proof Idea. If EE is the splitting field of ff and KK is a radical extension containing EE, then K/FK/F has a chain of cyclic extensions (adjoining roots of unity and nnth roots). The Galois group of each step is cyclic (hence abelian), so Gal⁡(K/F)\operatorname{Gal}(K/F) is solvable. Since Gal⁡(E/F)\operatorname{Gal}(E/F) is a quotient of Gal⁡(K/F)\operatorname{Gal}(K/F), it is solvable.∎

Theorem 14.21. Conversely, if GfG_f is solvable, then f(x)f(x) is solvable by radicals.

Theorem 14.22 (Galois's Criterion). A polynomial f(x)∈F[x]f(x) \in F[x] (with char⁡F=0\operatorname{char} F = 0) is solvable by radicals iff its Galois group GfG_f is solvable.

Example 14.23. S3S_3 is solvable, so every cubic over Q\mathbb{Q} is solvable by radicals. This is consistent with the cubic formula.

Example 14.24. S4S_4 is solvable, so every quartic over Q\mathbb{Q} is solvable by radicals. This is consistent with the quartic formula.

Example 14.25. S5S_5 is not solvable, so there exist quintics with Galois group S5S_5 that are not solvable by radicals.

Exercise 14.26. Explain why every quadratic, cubic, and quartic over Q\mathbb{Q} is solvable by radicals.

Exercise 14.27. Let f(x)∈Q[x]f(x) \in \mathbb{Q}[x] have Galois group A5A_5. Is ff solvable by radicals? Why or why not?

Exercise 14.28. Let f(x)∈Q[x]f(x) \in \mathbb{Q}[x] be an irreducible quintic with exactly two nonreal roots. Show that its Galois group contains a transposition.


Cyclotomic Extensions and Roots of Unity#

Definition 14.29. A cyclotomic extension of Q\mathbb{Q} is a field Q(ζn)\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_n) where ζn\zeta_n is a primitive nnth root of unity.

Theorem 14.30. The Galois group Gal⁡(Q(ζn)/Q)\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_n)/\mathbb{Q}) is isomorphic to (Z/nZ)×(\mathbb{Z}/n\mathbb{Z})^\times, the group of units modulo nn.

Theorem 14.31. Gal⁡(Q(ζn)/Q)\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_n)/\mathbb{Q}) is abelian.

Corollary 14.32. Cyclotomic extensions are solvable by radicals.

Example 14.33. For pp prime, Gal⁡(Q(ζp)/Q)≅Zp−1\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_p)/\mathbb{Q}) \cong \mathbb{Z}_{p-1}, which is cyclic.

Example 14.34. Gal⁡(Q(ζ8)/Q)≅Z2×Z2\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_8)/\mathbb{Q}) \cong \mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2.

Exercise 14.35. Compute Gal⁡(Q(ζ5)/Q)\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_5)/\mathbb{Q}).

Exercise 14.36. Show that Q(ζn)/Q\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_n)/\mathbb{Q} is always abelian.

Exercise 14.37. What is Gal⁡(Q(ζ12)/Q)\operatorname{Gal}(\mathbb{Q}(\zeta_{12})/\mathbb{Q})?


Constructible Numbers and Solvability#

Definition 14.38. A real number α\alpha is constructible if it can be obtained from 00 and 11 using finitely many operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and taking square roots.

Theorem 14.39. A real number α\alpha is constructible iff [Q(α):Q][\mathbb{Q}(\alpha):\mathbb{Q}] is a power of 22.

Corollary 14.40. The regular nn-gon is constructible with straightedge and compass iff φ(n)\varphi(n) is a power of 22.

Corollary 14.41. The cube cannot be doubled, the angle cannot be trisected, and the circle cannot be squared using straightedge and compass.

Exercise 14.42. Show that 23\sqrt[3]{2} is not constructible.

Exercise 14.43. Show that cos⁡20∘\cos 20^\circ is not constructible.

Exercise 14.44. Which regular nn-gons are constructible for n≤20n \leq 20?


Summary#

We have introduced:

  • Solvable groups and their properties
  • Radical extensions
  • Galois's criterion: solvable by radicals iff solvable Galois group
  • Cyclotomic extensions and their abelian Galois groups
  • Constructible numbers and their characterization
  • Classical impossibility results: doubling the cube, trisecting the angle, squaring the circle