This sheet culminates the course by proving the Abel-Ruffini theorem: there exist quintic polynomials that cannot be solved by radicals. We construct an explicit polynomial whose Galois group is S5S_5, which is not solvable.

Commentary. The Abel-Ruffini theorem is one of the most celebrated results in mathematics. It states that there is no formula (involving only addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and roots) that gives the solutions of every quintic polynomial. This does not mean that every quintic is unsolvable—indeed, x5−1x^5 - 1 is trivially solvable. Rather, it means that there exist quintics whose solutions cannot be expressed in radicals. The proof uses all the machinery we have developed: field extensions, Galois groups, and solvable groups. The result is not just negative—it explains why the quintic formula that mathematicians had sought for centuries does not exist.

Prerequisites. This sheet uses the following results from earlier sheets:

  • Solvable groups; subgroups of solvable groups are solvable (Sheet 14, Theorems 14.1, 14.3)
  • S5S_5 is not solvable (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.49; Sheet 14)
  • Galois's criterion: polynomial solvable by radicals iff its Galois group is solvable (Sheet 14, Theorem 14.22)
  • The Galois group of a polynomial is a subgroup of SnS_n (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.40)
  • Irreducible polynomials over Q\mathbb{Q} and Eisenstein's criterion (Sheet 9, Theorem 9.66)
  • Transpositions and 5-cycles in S5S_5; A5A_5 is simple (Sheet 2.5, Sheet 13)
  • The Fundamental Theorem of Galois Theory (Sheet 13, Theorem 13.33)
  • Splitting fields (Sheet 12)
  • Real roots of polynomials (calculus facts, assumed)

Review: S5S_5 Is Not Solvable#

Theorem 15.1. The symmetric group SnS_n is not solvable for n≥5n \geq 5.

Corollary 15.2. Every group containing A5A_5 as a subgroup is not solvable.

Exercise 15.3. Explain why S5S_5 is not solvable using the definition of solvable groups.


Strategy for the Quintic#

Lemma 15.4 (Sufficient Condition for Gf=S5G_f = S_5). Let f(x)∈Q[x]f(x) \in \mathbb{Q}[x] be irreducible of degree 55. Suppose:

  1. ff has exactly two nonreal roots (hence three real roots).
  2. The Galois group GfG_f contains a transposition (via complex conjugation).

Then Gf=S5G_f = S_5.

Exercise 15.5. Prove that a transitive subgroup of S5S_5 contains an element of order 55, and hence a 5-cycle.

Exercise 15.6. Show that a subgroup of S5S_5 containing a 5-cycle and a transposition is all of S5S_5.


An Explicit Non-Solvable Quintic#

Theorem 15.7. The polynomial f(x)=x5−5x+2∈Q[x]f(x) = x^5 - 5x + 2 \in \mathbb{Q}[x] is not solvable by radicals.

Exercise 15.8. Verify that f(x)=x5−5x+2f(x) = x^5 - 5x + 2 is irreducible over Q\mathbb{Q} by applying Eisenstein's criterion to a suitable shift f(x+1)f(x+1) or f(x+2)f(x+2).

Exercise 15.9. Show that f(x)=x5−5x+2f(x) = x^5 - 5x + 2 has no rational roots. Why does this alone not prove irreducibility for quintics?

Exercise 15.10. Verify the sign analysis for f(−1)f(-1) and f(1)f(1), and explain why this implies at least three real roots.


The Abel-Ruffini Theorem#

Theorem 15.11 (Abel-Ruffini). There exists a polynomial of degree 55 over Q\mathbb{Q} that is not solvable by radicals. Hence there is no general formula for solving quintic equations by radicals.

Exercise 15.12. Explain why the existence of one non-solvable quintic implies there is no universal radical formula for all quintics.


Classification of Quintic Galois Groups#

Theorem 15.13. For an irreducible quintic over Q\mathbb{Q}, the possible Galois groups (as subgroups of S5S_5) are:S5,A5,F⁡20,D5,C5.S_5, \quad A_5, \quad \operatorname{F}_{20}, \quad D_5, \quad C_5.

Theorem 15.14. If the discriminant of ff is a square in Q\mathbb{Q}, then Gf⊆A5G_f \subseteq A_5. Otherwise, GfG_f contains odd permutations.

Theorem 15.15. If GfG_f is S5S_5 or A5A_5, then ff is not solvable by radicals.

Theorem 15.16. If GfG_f is C5C_5, D5D_5, or F⁡20\operatorname{F}_{20}, then ff is solvable by radicals.

Example 15.17. f(x)=x5−x−1f(x) = x^5 - x - 1 has Galois group S5S_5, hence is not solvable.

Example 15.18. f(x)=x5−2f(x) = x^5 - 2 has Galois group F⁡20\operatorname{F}_{20}, hence is solvable.

Exercise 15.19. Compute the discriminant of x5−5x+2x^5 - 5x + 2 and determine whether it is a square.

Exercise 15.20. Explain why a quintic with Galois group A5A_5 is not solvable by radicals.


Historical Context#

Definition 15.21. The Abel-Ruffini theorem states that there is no general formula for solving polynomial equations of degree 55 or higher using radicals.

Historical Note. Niels Henrik Abel proved the theorem in 1824, but his proof was incomplete. Évariste Galois provided the complete theory in 1830, introducing the concepts of Galois groups and solvability. His work was not fully appreciated until after his death in 1832.

Remark. The insolvability of the quintic does not mean that all quintics are impossible to solve. Many quintics are solvable by radicals, including x5−1x^5 - 1 and x5−2x^5 - 2. The theorem says that there is no universal formula that works for every quintic.


Generalizations#

Theorem 15.22. For any n≥5n \geq 5, there exists an irreducible polynomial of degree nn over Q\mathbb{Q} with Galois group SnS_n.

Corollary 15.23. For any n≥5n \geq 5, there exists a polynomial of degree nn over Q\mathbb{Q} that is not solvable by radicals.


Summary#

We have proven:

  • S5S_5 is not solvable
  • f(x)=x5−5x+2f(x) = x^5 - 5x + 2 is irreducible over Q\mathbb{Q}
  • f(x)f(x) has exactly three real roots and two nonreal roots
  • Therefore Gal⁡(f)≅S5\operatorname{Gal}(f) \cong S_5
  • Since S5S_5 is not solvable, ff is not solvable by radicals
  • Hence the quintic is, in general, unsolvable by radicals

Final Summary of the Course#

We have journeyed from the foundations of sets and functions through:

  • Group theory: subgroups, cosets, Lagrange's theorem, normal subgroups, quotient groups, isomorphism theorems, group actions, Sylow theorems, solvable groups
  • Matrix theory: eigenvalues, minimal polynomial, rational canonical form, Jordan canonical form
  • Ring theory: integral domains, fields, ideals, quotient rings, polynomial rings, UFDs, PIDs
  • Field theory: algebraic extensions, splitting fields, algebraic closures, finite fields
  • Galois theory: automorphisms, fixed fields, Galois groups, the Galois correspondence, solvability by radicals
  • The crowning achievement: the insolvability of the quintic